A Murder of Crow

Wed May 14 10:18:13 -0700 2008

Looking out the window this morning, I saw an abundance of flies. They're a constant annoyance but this was a remarkable display of so many, so excited. I wondered why.

Wandering out, I found the yard absolutely strewn with crow feathers. Some poor bird got picked clean. The carcass is nowhere in sight -- hopefully it get et up.

No topic post would be complete without a link to some neat science. Without further ado, a recently posted Ted video considers the relationship between crow and man.

Spoilers below the fold for those who can't or don't want to watch the video. And some reflections on the one that died here last night (and my role in the crime).

The Ted talk's thesis is, in my view, a rediscovery of the concept of domesticating wild animals. The speaker observes that crows are found everywhere there are people other than the arctic, and rarely nest more than 5km from people. While some regard them as pests to be eradicated, he proposes managing them with the aim of co-evolution, exploiting the intelligence of crows to perform useful work. The speaker built a "crow vending machine" to illustrate the potential. In just four steps he taught wild crows to gather scattered coins, drop them in a slot, and get a peanut. He's not sure there's enough loose change on the streets to form a business model out of that, but it is a proof of concept.

The talk includes a video clip from a scientific experiment. A wild crow that uses sticks as tools was in a lab, challenged to remove meat from a narrow tube using a stiff wire. After a time, the crow came up with some original behavior (shown in the video): it took a moment away from fishing for meat to go off and bend the wire, forming a hook. With the hook, it retrieved the meat easily. "This is the point where the researchers freak out," quipped the speaker.

The talk includes other clips and stories of remarkable displays of intelligence by crows.


I'd like to honor the crow who died here, probably early this morning. This is especially because I'm pretty sure I met this particular crow just yesterday and played a role in its demise.

As a favor to the owners of the place, I was helping water the sod. That is my complicity. I'd step out, every N minutes, to move a sprinkler around.

In the dry weather we've been having, the sprinkler is a perpetual treat for birds. Robins come to bathe -- that's kind of cool. A fun treat to watch is the hummingbirds who hover, dancing with the back and forth motion of the sprinkler, using it as half-shower / half-water-fountain.

Yesterday was unusual for the appearance of this crow, bathing and drinking. Don't see that much.

This particular crow was not in the good graces of the local murder. As he bathed and drank, from the nest and tree above came many screams. There was shouting back and forth. But, dangit, fresh water isn't abundant on the city streets these days and he shouted right back and stood his ground.

He stood his ground this much: when I went out to move the sprinkler, sure, he fluttered away a few feet -- but then stood there and started shouting at me. I spritzed him with the sprinkler as I moved it as a friendly gesture. He seemed to appreciate that. After I set it down and as I walked away he advanced on me a bit and shouted some more -- but it seemed very pro forma, actually. We'd understood one another. He got back to bathing and drinking and ignoring the angry crows in the tree.

A fresh watering attracts more than just birds. The insects go nuts. It used to bring up worms (though I haven't seen more than 2 or 3 this year). And that brings the raccoons.

These are big, aggressive, urban raccoons. These are the guys who, if I encounter them at night, are 50/50 likely to scoot away or, alternatively, perch up on their hind legs, rising well above my waste, and give me an "out o' my way, buddy" look.

And that's all I know. I helped try (somewhat futilely) to soak the sod in anticipation of water rationing and triple-digit temps. That brought the crow. It probably brought the raccoons. And this morning, the yard is littered with the signs of a murder of crow -- and a lot of flies.

Wherever you are is at least as interesting and probably more so. Spend some time, quietly, every day, looking at the wild life. Use all of your senses. Learn where you are. Start to figure out how you can make sense of living there.

-t

 
A Murder of Crow
Wed May 14 23:14:45 -0700 2008

I'd say the most likely culprit would be the semi-domesticated neighborhood cats.

An old roommate of mine had a cat that took down a crow but didn't kill it for a while resulting in a crippled crow hopping around the back yard for a while. The crow was never seen again...eventually.

Evil, evil cats.

 
A Murder of Crow
Thu May 15 09:17:57 -0700 2008

Wow!

Cat isn't a crazy guess. I didn't think so at first because it's apparent from the distribution of feathers that this bird didn't go down easy yet there's no cat fur in sight and we didn't hear any cat screams.

You made me curious, though, so I looked for evidence.

It started with watering the lawn, remember? And there's a plant bed that also got watered. So there is a convenient mud patch there. See where I'm going with this?

Guess what? Yes, there is a big ol' raccoon footprint right next to where the meal was presumably consumed (the big patch of downy feathers in contrast to the scattered outer feathers).

-t

 
A Murder of Crow
Thu May 15 05:32:52 -0700 2008

Crows also mourn the dead. They will gather around a dead crow and stay for hours, or even all day, and will try to keep other animals (including humans) away.

 
A Murder of Crow
Thu May 15 09:03:01 -0700 2008

Interesting, because exactly that happened -- although there are probably two factors.

I was showing the crime scene to my wife last evening and we were definitely shouted away by other crows. Yesterday, a couple of us also had the impression we were seeing unusual behavior from the other crows -- swooping around the scene and shouting a lot.

The other factor is: I haven't found it but I'm pretty sure there's a nest nearby. I can hear what sounds like nestlings at various times of day. My guess is that part of why the other crows were yelling at the one bathing -- the one I think died -- was a territory thing.

-t

 
A Murder of Crow
Thu May 15 14:50:52 -0700 2008

AFAIK Konrad Lorenz detected their exceptionnal intelligence more than 80 years ago(?)

 
A Murder of Crow
Fri May 16 07:01:26 -0700 2008

Very interesting Talk that you linked to, thanks for making taking me down this path on a Friday morning. Looks like alot of good stuff on TED

 
A Murder of Crow
Fri May 16 09:13:36 -0700 2008

And, thank you for the encouraging feedback.

Ted's a mixed bag but there's a lot there that's entertaining and a non-random amount that I regard as offering some semblance of hope in this tired old world. (I'll save the scathing criticisms of some of the talks for other days :-)

-t